Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts

Wednesday, 10 February 2010

Review: An Education

The 'serious' newspaper reviews rated it worthy, best film of year (2009) so far and there is this Oscar buzz about it. Worth a visit, no not really, just much better than all the other dross out there.
Just light and frothy.
There was a scatter gun of cliches covering most of the familiar 60's issues. Poised at the brink of the changes the sixties swept in, they are all there, challenge to establishment, woman emancipation, life aspiration, sexual revolution, 'pop' culture, material consumerism, exploitation of the vulnerable, racism but in true soap-operaesque, having klaxtoned the emotional hook limply failed to get beyond or beneath the trite superficial observation, leaving us just with tabloid headliners.
Light and fluffy.
What a waste of talent and effort as the actors struggled to imply meaning deeper than the script offered them. It was not hammy but might as well been for all the absence of content and lack of conviction or empathy generated. I'm afraid no matter how well acted twenty three years doing seventeen does not adequately carry conviction in close-up and the snappy facing out of authority figures dialogue struck me more as wane nostalgia of a wistful middle-age woman looking to self-justify her lack of younger judgement than youthful emergent woman coming to terms with her sexuality, life and opportunities.
Light and fluffy.
Nothing wrong in light and fluffy, a bit of escapism, great, a soaring adventure, great, a fresh camper around familiar scenes, maybe, a step back in time to re-assess our path, maybe. It doesn't always have to have lasting impact getting deep under the skin of relationship issues but we, who have turned out and paid the front office, do deserve something to immerse ourselves into, to get carried away or taken to a fresh place or given a fresh view. A bit more than this soap-opera offering.
Light and fluffy, but lacking in substance.
Surprisingly perhaps our thin audience was fellow late middle-aged couples hoping for a nostalgic look back at their missed opportunities? All in all a couple of hours of pleasant but so wide of the mark missed opportunities.

Thursday, 26 November 2009

Harry Brown

Reassured by the great British public, 66% thought it almost fantastic, we went to see Harry Brown. A very bleak film. Fine, bleak is good, some of the toughest social issues lurk in these dark corners.

Expectations running high, we lurch through one ludicrous implausible plot shift to another as one hackneyed cliché after another, after another is trotted out. There are occasional hints of originality with a fresh take but these, after the initial languid absorbing scene setting opening, never develop or find any legs. Instead it accelerates into cheap kicks with gratuitous drug taking, violence and violence against women. Whatever creative drive it started out with was quickly used up and there were no reserve Plan B's to call on. Even the final crescendo of violence cannot be left as a climatic end with three, in teach yourself detail, dead and two in doubt, but, has to whimper off into a limp-wristed apology of a soppy nonsensical soft landing.

Oh Micheal Caine, that you gave authority to and your great performance should have been wasted on such unmitigated dross.